CS 121 Rubric

Proposal Rubric

Evaluation Considerations

Category Attribute Plus/Check/Minus

Background and Problem High level problem is described in detail in a manner understandable by all

Problem context is described

Need for solving problem is articulated as is the impact of the solution

Report contains ample references to the literature and web

Deliverables clearly enumerated

Requirements Analysis Functional Requirements elaborated and prioritized

Non-Functional Requirements elaborated and prioritized

Problems/Risks identified and discussed

Game Design Proposed game is well described, including their, characters, and gameplay mechanics

Underlying models, e.g., scoring are discussed even though not fully developed

Report conveys the look and feel of the game

Development Plan (technology and risk assessment)Writing Discussion of technology and of risk assessment)

Writing Abstract provides a summary of the project and game.

Clear flow and progression of topics across all sections and within each section

Spell check and grammar check

Reasonable sentence & paragraph structure

Appropriate Tone - CS121 prof/grutors & MS teachers

Quality of Proposed Solution Concise statement of problem and solution appears in Introduction

Game will be fun

Game will be effective in achieving learning objectives

Team has identified major risks and plans for mitigating them

Success possible

NOTES:

While items, e.g., risks, are listed in specific sections, those sections are really the most likely location, not the required location. Using risks as an example, because PyGame and other tools are specified, the risks might be more associated with an aspect of the game rather than with the requirements.

Proposal Rubric

NOTES:

Team:

Grade(20, 15, 9, 0)

Comments:

Proposal Rubric
Evaluation Considerations
Category	Attribute	Plus/Check/Minus
Background and Problem	High level problem is described in detail in a manner understandable by all
	Problem context is described
	Need for solving problem is articulated as is the impact of the solution
	Report contains ample references to the literature and web
	Deliverables clearly enumerated
Requirements Analysis	Functional Requirements elaborated and prioritized
	Non-Functional Requirements elaborated and prioritized
	Problems/Risks identified and discussed
Game Design	Proposed game is well described, including their, characters, and gameplay mechanics
	Underlying models, e.g., scoring are discussed even though not fully developed
	Report conveys the look and feel of the game
Development Plan (technology and risk assessment)Writing	Discussion of technology and of risk assessment)
Writing	Abstract provides a summary of the project and game.
	Clear flow and progression of topics across all sections and within each section
	Spell check and grammar check
	Reasonable sentence & paragraph structure
	Appropriate Tone - CS121 prof/grutors & MS teachers
Quality of Proposed Solution	Concise statement of problem and solution appears in Introduction
	Game will be fun
	Game will be effective in achieving learning objectives
	Team has identified major risks and plans for mitigating them
	Success possible