Who's the best? JamesTKirk
? That dude from DS9? (That would be Benjamin Sisko
's character on Enterporn? (That would be Jonathan Archer
) Expostulate and debate here.
Janeway. End of discussion.
I beg to differ! JeanLucPicard?
fits the bill, hands down. Starfleet needs more Shakespearean captains. --WillShipley
Yes, more Shakespearean captains! Which is precisely the reason Avery Brooks was cast as Benjamin Sisko.
I mean, dude, he should at least get some credit for becoming a demi-god. Plus, his mildly Kirkesque speech pattern actually works for him. --MarkSandoval
Who would win in a fight? Clearly Kirk. Also, who gets the most women (besides Janeway?) Also Kirk. Clearly this counts in his favor on diplomatic missions --MatthewLawson
- Sisko might hold his own in a fight against Kirk. And, unlike Kirk, Sisko can maintain long-term relationships. Who is the only captain to have punched Q, again? --RichardBowen
- While an awesome scene, I must point out that it is irrelevant to the discussion, as he was a commander at the time, and this discussion is about the best captain. On that note, CLEARLY Pike. Forget Kirk's women, he gets the green ones. --JasonWinerip